Video Exports

How to Deliver HDR Video With an SDR Version

Prepare separate HDR and SDR exports, then compare highlight rolloff, skin and shadows on suitable displays.

Separate the HDR master from the SDR delivery version before you start exporting. Pick one shot with bright highlights, one with a recognizable face and one with shadow detail. Those three shots make a short sequence you can check on both kinds of display before reviewing the entire program.

Write the requested signal and destination beside each planned file. A client with a standard display may need a separate Rec. 709 export. For a platform that generates its own SDR playback, plan to check the converted result there as well. Name the deliverables so a reviewer can choose the right one. Verify the actual color tags in each file, since those tell the player how to interpret its signal.

Create two versions from known color settings

For YouTube HDR, the platform's HDR requirements specify 10 or 12 bits, Rec. 2020 primaries, a Rec. 2020 non-constant luminance matrix and a PQ or HLG transfer function. They also describe the metadata expected for proper HDR detection. Set the timeline, monitoring and export to the agreed HDR workflow. Keep a note of whether you used PQ or HLG so the reviewer can select matching playback. Changing a tag alone leaves the encoded color values as they were.

Make the SDR version through an actual HDR-to-SDR conversion. For example, Apple's Color Conform guide documents HLG and PQ conversions for a Rec. 709 SDR project in Final Cut Pro. Use the conversion that matches the source. The app also has a legacy HDR Tools effect. Choose Color Conform or the legacy effect for a clip. Apple notes that both applied together compound their conversions.

Compare three difficult shots

Sample Watch for in SDR
Reflections or a bright window Distinct bright details still visible as levels roll into the top of the SDR range
A familiar skin tone A believable balance of color and saturation after the transfer
A dark interior Important folds or objects remain distinguishable without raising all shadows

Open the HDR export on an HDR-capable display with the intended mode active. Reopen the SDR export on an ordinary SDR screen. Compare the three shots using the exported files on their intended displays. Look again at the tags and export settings if the picture appears washed out or if the HDR device plays it like an SDR file. Use the waveform and other scopes in your grading setup to compare both versions as you revise the conversion.

YouTube generates an SDR rendition when it recognizes the HDR upload. Review that rendition on an SDR device separately from any manually graded SDR file you deliver to your client. When delivering both files, put the transfer function and deliverable role in the manifest. This lets the recipient choose the intended asset without inferring its color settings from a poster frame.

Start with the intended person and screen

Ask where each file will be viewed. A colourist might use a properly configured HDR reference screen and want a master in a specific transfer function. A client might view an SDR proof in a browser and need an independent copy that does not depend on the platform's HDR conversion. Write both expectations in the delivery plan before grading. The HDR master, a manually tailored SDR file and a platform-generated SDR playback are three separate observations.

Choose the three reference shots from the edit and add their timecodes to the plan. A bright window should let you see whether important texture survives in SDR. A familiar face helps compare skin tone and hue. An interior helps you see whether shadows still separate the objects that matter. Take a short test through the chosen HDR and SDR paths before exporting the full program. Keep the shots in their actual order if the transition from dark to bright is part of the intended effect.

If the source consists of material with mixed colour spaces, check how each clip enters the timeline. Choose the appropriate input interpretation for the test before changing the destination. A clip tagged wrongly or transformed twice can look washed out even on a compatible screen. Use the grade and export controls the editor documents. Compare the scopes with a known reference shot in the same project and verify the actual export and its tags.

Find where a bad colour result was introduced

Symptom in the test What to inspect
The HDR device opens the file as SDR Delivery export tags, signal requirements and the display's mode
The preview shows clipped highlights, with visible detail in the HDR source The HDR-to-SDR conversion and treatment of bright regions
Only one previously converted clip looks wrong Input interpretation and whether two transforms affect that clip
The local SDR master looks fine but online SDR differs Whether the player is showing its generated SDR rendition

After selecting the target colour space, recheck that the exported signals match the corresponding tags. Retagging mislabelled bytes may solve a metadata problem, but making an SDR deliverable from HDR usually involves converting the values. If the SDR highlights lack detail, inspect the conversion on the bright shot and find out which levels and saturation need adjustment. If the face becomes unnatural while neutral details look correct, compare the grade and source profile separately.

Open the export from the delivery folder, outside the grading application when possible. Use an HDR display for the HDR copy and an SDR setup for the SDR copy, with the intended mode enabled. Check timecodes and audio in both files. A colour conversion should not replace an audio mix or change the cut. After uploading the HDR version to a platform, inspect its processed state and play the SDR rendition on an SDR device if that is part of the expected route.

Record what belongs to each deliverable

Include the master role, transfer function, revision and relevant colour space in the delivery note. Add what you tested on each screen and whether a separately graded SDR version exists. The person accepting it should be able to choose the intended file without reading the image by eye. Include the matching caption track if applicable. Use the delivery manifest example to keep the revision and playback proof beside both files.

When replacing one version, recheck the same bright, midtone and shadow examples on the new export. If the project changed after the reference grade, confirm both versions still contain the intended pictures and no temporary graphics. Archive the accepted master with the underlying information that lets another editor reproduce the SDR copy later.

Sources