Edit Setup

When Are Proxies Worth Making for a 4K Edit?

Run a short proxy test and compare the time and storage it takes with the time it saves during the edit.

Make proxies for the hardest minute of the 4K edit before starting an encoder queue for the shoot. Use material with the same compression, frame rate and number of angles as the real project. A camera file that plays well by itself may behave differently when you scrub a multi-angle sequence.

Proxies are editing copies associated with original media. Premiere's proxy instructions describe choosing a frame size and preset and attaching generated files to project clips. Final Cut Pro's proxy guide offers its own resolution and codec choices. Keep the app and settings in the test record so a new batch uses the same conditions.

Compare the work you are actually doing

Make a short sequence with an ordinary cut, a fast move across the timeline and an effect or angle change you expect to use. Run the original first. Count playback stops, note how long it takes to find two marked frames and record whether dropped frames make it difficult to judge a cut. Then create proxies, switch playback to those media and repeat the same actions.

Record wall-clock encoding time, how much of that time someone must attend, and the added disk space. In a hypothetical edit, creating proxies takes 12 minutes in the background and three minutes of operator time. If they save two minutes of waiting in each of eight editing sessions, the edit gains 16 minutes against three minutes of active setup. If the laptop is unusable during encoding, count the 12 minutes in the schedule too. When delivery is close, compare when you can start cutting with either setup.

Keep the connection to the originals visible

Give the proxy folder a predictable location beside or within the project package. Verify that audio stays aligned and that the editing version has the expected frame and channel arrangement. Some media or configurations have extra attachment requirements, so test one clip with the real audio before queuing the rest.

Keep a small chart of which clips needed proxies. A new camera codec or an extra playback angle can change the result. Test the same minute again before adopting last project's proxy settings for a laptop with different storage or cooling.

Switch to the originals for critical focus checks, color judgements and the final export workflow you intend to use. Reopen the project and export a small section to verify which source the app uses under your settings. If both kinds of media play smoothly, work with the originals for the easy clips. Make proxies for the angle groups or long-GOP files whose measured delays would otherwise interrupt editing.

Build a test an editor can repeat

Choose one piece of footage you know will be in the real edit. In a concert shoot, that could be the second chorus where all four cameras are visible in the angle viewer. Include a cut on a beat, a short scrub backwards, and a switch to a camera with a different recording format. Set markers at the start and end so you can repeat the same actions with both sets of media. Keep your audio monitoring and timeline settings the same.

Count the waits you feel in normal editing. You might measure the time between clicking a marker and seeing its frame, or the number of times you have to replay a cut because playback stumbled. Keep those observations separate. A proxy might make scrubbing feel faster without helping a section that spends most of its time rendering a heavy effect. If you only judge the sequence by how long it takes to export, you may miss the improvement you created for editing.

Do a pass with the same effect temporarily disabled. If the original and proxy both become easy to play, the first problem to solve could be the effect. If you still see delays while switching between cameras and the proxy pass helps, try proxies for that angle group first. Write down the playback setting used in each run. A proxy comparison where you also changed the output monitor or enabled a pre-render has more than one plausible explanation.

Estimate space with actual clips

Take a short clip from each camera type you expect to proxy. Generate a proxy at the proposed settings and look at the disk space used after creation. Use the resulting sizes to plan by recorded hour. If a two-minute trial produces 240 MB, 60 minutes of similar material would use about 7.2 GB at the same measured rate. An interview with three recorded cameras for that hour can bring the estimate to about 21.6 GB if the three rates match. Variable data rates and interruptions in recording can change the actual total. Measure a different sample for a camera or setting that behaves differently.

Keep original storage separate in the calculation. The proxy files are another set of files on top of the source media and may compete for room with renders, caches and delivery exports. A full scratch drive halfway through a job makes the proxy decision harder to reverse. If the estimate is close to available space, start with the clips that interrupted editing in the rehearsal and leave enough room for the work you have to export.

Check detail before choosing a smaller proxy

For a dialogue edit you may be able to use a small frame and still judge the timing. For a product close-up you might need to read tiny text or see a focus change. Compare the frame that gives you the least room for error. Try an ordinary cut with the smaller file and then examine the same shot using the original. Keep the original review step in the plan when it changes a decision about a shot. An optional proxy watermark can make the playback state apparent to a second editor watching the screen. Premiere's Create Proxies dialog includes that option.

Give someone receiving the project one clear place to look for the proxy files. In the project note, list separate paths for originals and proxies and say which folders need to be copied for the destination to use them. If the person receiving it will work on the same project, have them reopen a small copy and check that both media states are available before transferring the whole shoot. For a wider transfer, use the editable project handoff checklist.

Make the day-of delivery choice from your rehearsal. If the original media lets you place the cuts on time and judge the details, you can skip a proxy batch. If the rehearsal keeps failing at the same set of angles, generate that set first. Run the same marked sequence after the transcode so you can see whether the extra files solved the interruption you measured.

Sources